I know it's a common question, but I have checked with https://broadinstitute.org/gatk/guide/article?id=1235 and I'm quite confident the problem lies elsewhere.
I have a trio with a high quality SNP passed from dad to proband.
I am running HaplotypeCaller in basepair resolution mode, one individual at a time, and then processing as usual through the "N+1" pipeline.
The variant in the proband's GVCF is called at high quality: "0/1:63,55,0:118:99:1383,0,1709,1571,1873,3445:24,39,19,36"
However, that position in the dad's GVCF is not called: "0/0:52,52:104:0:0,0,168"
despite noting 52 alt reads out of a total of 104 reads. The GQ is 0. This is using both the official release of 3.5, and the latest nightly build (as of today).
If I use an older version of GATK, 3.1, the variant in the dad is found at high quality: "0/1:52,49,0:101:99:1086,0,1397,1245,1541,2786:16,36,16,33"
with 49 alt reads out of 101 and a GQ of 99.
At this point, I'm not sure what to do. I'd prefer not to have to recall my 10k+ samples with version 3.1!
I sent a reproducible snippet to the ftp server, with commands, etc.
Thanks,
Jason